This is a tough book to grade. Book is flat and fairly clean, but has a few major defects, including a couple color breaking folds and cover tears. That said, it presents really nice, is well hydrated with off-white pages. I think its possible CGC would go above 4.0 but I'm being cautious. I am not a professional grader. This is based on my best assessment from my experience submitting dozens of books to CGC.